Offbeat - Adopt Vs Co-Opt
Wednesday, Mar 7, 2018
MARCH 7, 2018 by: JAN RAMSEY
Right after the March issue that features Dancing Man 504 (Darryl Young) on the cover hit the street, we received a letter from the chief of a local Mardi Gras Indian tribe. He was upset about Dancing Man’s “co-opting” Mardi Gras Indian culture.
I kind of understand his resentment, but I have to say that I think Darryl’s joy in dancing, and getting others to do the same, and his efforts to give back to the community, isn’t necessarily co-opting the Mardi Gras Indian and second line traditions. All he is doing is bringing more attention to our traditions, not stealing them or trying to tell anyone that what he does is the same as a Mardi Gras Indian.
In his letter the chief pointed out, rightly, that the many social aid and pleasure clubs were started as benevolent societies whose purpose was to help to take care of their immediate community’s needs, like, for example, funeral expenses and other expenses. He perceived Mr. Young as a “culture vulture” who was stealing our traditions—just like many others who are making “millions of it.”
I don’t see Darryl Young as a culture vulture.
I think that we need to all understand that those vultures also include people like the guys who stand around the Quarter in Mardi Gras Indian dress and charge people for taking a photo with them? How about the convention companies and meeting planners who arrange “second line parades” with bunches of tourists walking down the street waving their hankies in the air, and led by a local brass band? Or what about the Mardi Gras Indians who perform the traditional chants and perform on stage as a band? Or if you really want to get picky, how about how our Mardi Gras traditions of parading and costuming that have been promoted to the world for the benefit of the city’s economy–filling hotel rooms and restaurants? Couldn’t that also be considered “co-opting” the culture?
Nothing is so cut and dried. I see that our culture and traditions can and will be co-opted for money, and that’s a shame, but it’s not ever going to change. Once people see the opportunity to have fun, dance, celebrate, eat and party—-and especially to make a buck—using New Orleans cultural traditions as a base, it’s just going to happen.
I may have mentioned this before, but the Bike Easy group started using the term “Bike Second Line” to get people to participate in their programs. I actually was a bit offended by them using that term. Once I met the Bike Easy organizer, it occurred to me that we should be flattered that our traditions have been “adopted,” not “co-opted.” There’s a difference. We shouldn’t be offended; traditions will be absorbed and changed as time goes by, but it is up to the culture creators and bearers to continue to make sure that they educate the adopters on the source of the tradition and to make sure that they remain strong and pure within their own milieu; to educate others on the tradition’s roots; and of course, to pass on their purity to younger generations.
We can’t be afraid of change. Our culture bearers have to use it to their benefit to keep the traditions alive and well. It can be done.
What’s your opinion on this? Take our Weekly Poll and give us your opinion.
See all articles in the News Archives